Rock Band 2 Review
Posted by Tim Gilbreath
So I’ve spent the last month or so (since I got Guitar Hero World Tour for the Wii) debunking any claims that I heard about the supremacy of Rock Band over the Guitar Hero franchise. This is, of course, without even playing the game. I just knew that Guitar Hero was better.
After purchasing Rock Band 2 for the Wii this weekend and spending several hours with it, I’ve come to the conclusion that having both franchises around is nothing short of a wonderful thing for us rythym-game lovers.
Guitar Hero World Tour (and to a lesser extent, Guitar Hero III) is a kick-ass game; the first weekend we probably averaged 6 hours per day playing it between my wife, myself, and my kid. There’s hardly anything I can say I don’t like about the game, but I can say now that there are things that were improved in my opinion with Rock Band 2.
The major issue I have with Rock Band is the appearance of the highway (the highway is the scrolling “fretboard” that the notes appear on, for you Guitar Hero/Rock Band virgins); the notes are thin bars, and in the middle of the action, for example, during a collection of energy powerups, they can be a bit hard to see. The notes in guitar hero are large, colorized circles, and I’ve never had an issue seeing them. It’s not that Rock Band made it more challenging with the bars, it’s more like they made it more frustrating.
And that’s where my gripes about Rock Band end, I found the Touring mode more realistic and enjoyable (perhaps because I’m a musician myself, my wife and daughter don’t share my views), and the characters and audience rendered better than on Guitar Hero. The song selection was very good, although I have to say that Guitar Hero World Tour had a better collection of songs in my opinion. Through all this however, the downloadable content that will be available (and is already available for Rock Band 2 on the PS3 and the XBOX 360) will shame anything that Guitar Hero has to offer. The catalog for the PS3 and XBOX are already over 300 songs, and it’s been stated that the Wii will eventually have access to the entire catalog.
The biggest selling point to me was the fact that Rock Band 2 is completely compatible with Guitar Hero World Tour instruments; so I didn’t have to go out and buy the whole band kit, I was able to buy the standalone game (which I got a great deal on thanks to a trade-in) and start playing immediately with the instruments I already had. Can’t beat it.
So all in all, I think we benefit from both franchises as gamers, as they both have awesome selling points, but if you’re a Guitar Hero fanboy, don’t miss out on the fun by not giving Rock Band 2 a chance.
